Stay up to date with the latest wedding ceremony trends, script writing inspiration, tips and advice for first-time officiants, and news that matters to couples and wedding ministers.

Indiana Attorney General Asks SCOTUS to Overturn Protections for Same-Sex Parents

Published Tuesday, Dec. 1st, 2020

Indiana’s Attorney General is asking the US Supreme Court to reverse a federal appeals court’s ruling that allows married, same-sex parents to both be named on their children’s birth certificates. This is one of the first cases dealing with same-sex marriage brought to the Supreme Court since Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s confirmation. 


(Read What Justice Amy Coney Barrett's Confirmation Means for the Future of Same-Sex Marriage.)


The brief submitted by Attorney General Curtis Hill was filed when, earlier this year, the U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a decision made by the state’s federal Southern District court, after judges there ruled that laws preventing married same-sex couples from both being named as parents on a birth certificate went against the constitutional protections established by the Fourteenth Amendment that same-sex couples be treated identically to opposite-sex couples, as demonstrated with Obergefell v Hodges


The original case, Box v Henderson, was filed in 2015 by Ruby and Ashlee Henderson, when county officials refused to list both of them as mothers on the birth certificate after their son was conceived through the help of artificial insemination. 


(You can read more about Box v Henderson and the January appeals court ruling in Slate: After 32 Month Delay, 7th Circuit Affirms Equal Rights for Same-Sex Parents.)


In January of 2020, the 7th Circuit Court judges wrote that “a husband is presumed to be a child’s biological father, so that both spouses are listed as parents on the birth certificate and the child is deemed to be born in wedlock,” but that “There’s no similar presumption with respect to an all-female married couple — or for that matter an all-male married couple.” (As reported by the Journal & Courier and Indianapolis Star.)


They added that allowing both mothers (and fathers) in a same-sex marriage to be listed as parents would prevent any discrimination to these LGBTQ families. Hill disagrees, and is arguing that the Supreme Court should overturn the lower court’s decision. He argues that a second same-sex parent would need to first adopt a child (paying an adoption fee) before a second birth certificate could be issued.


This case is of great interest to us at AMM for obvious reasons. We believe strongly that the benefits and protections of marriage should be available to all couples and their families, equally and without discrimination.


To limit same-sex parents in this way is unconstitutional, would be a blow to the rights of LGBTQ families, and would undermine the very foundations of marriage equality. We hope that our new Supreme Court lineup sees it the same way, and we’ll be paying close attention to their decision. 


The Supreme Court is scheduled to discuss the case on December 11th

Jessica Levey
Jessica Levey

Lead Staff Writer & Illustrator

Jessica loves exploring the history and magic of ritual, the connections between people and places, and sharing true stories about love and commitment. She's an advocate for marriage equality, LGBTQ+ rights, and individuality, and is an ordained Minister with AMM. When she’s not writing or illustrating for AMM, she enjoys city hikes, fantasy novels, comics, and traveling.

Natasha Anakotta
Natasha Anakotta

Guest Contributor

Natasha is passionate about promoting marriage equality, and encouraging couples to celebrate in a way that’s authentic and unique. Aside from weddings, she enjoys Star Wars, true crime podcasts, and eating macarons by the dozen.

How To Officiate By State

Will You Marry Us? Gift Package

Who Will Officiate Your Wedding?

Choose Your Officiant with our "Will You Marry Us?" Gift Package.

Signature Wedding Officiant Package

Signature Wedding Officiant Package

Our premiere package contains everyting you need to officiate like a pro.

The Book of Wedding Vows and Ceremonies

The Book of Wedding Vows and Ceremonies

It's finally here! Timeless scripts and heartfelt vow inspiration to bring life to your ceremony.

Professional Wedding Officiant Certification Course

Learn from the Pros to Officiate with Confidence!

Wedding Officiant Training

Wedding Officiant Training

Everything you need to know to officiate.

Read our sample wedding ceremony scripts online

Sample Wedding Ceremony Scripts

Need inspiration? Check out our free ceremony scripts!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter!


Become a Wedding Officiant with Our Free Online Ordination!